Ocean Carbon & Biogeochemistry
Studying marine ecosystems and biogeochemical cycles in the face of environmental change
  • Home
  • About OCB
    • About Us
    • Get Involved
    • Project Office
    • Code of Conduct
    • Scientific Steering Committee
    • OCB committees
      • Ocean Time-series
      • US Biogeochemical-Argo
      • Ocean-Atmosphere Interaction
    • Scientific Breadth
      • Biological Pump
      • Changing Marine Ecosystems
      • Changing Ocean Chemistry
      • Estuarine and Coastal Carbon Fluxes
      • Ocean Carbon Uptake and Storage
      • Ocean Observatories
  • Activities
    • OCB Webinar Series
    • Summer Workshops
    • Scoping Workshops
    • Other Workshops
    • Science Planning
      • Coastal CARbon Synthesis (CCARS)
      • North Atlantic-Arctic
    • Ocean Acidification PI Meetings
    • Training Activities
  • Small Group Activities
    • Aquatic Continuum OCB-NACP Focus Group
    • CMIP6 WG
      • CMIP6 Models Workshop
    • Filling the gaps air–sea carbon fluxes WG
    • Fish Carbon WG
      • Fish Carbon WG Workshop
      • Fish carbon workshop summary
    • GO-BCG OCB-US CLIVAR Scoping Workshop
    • Lateral Carbon Flux in Tidal Wetlands
    • Metaproteomic Intercomparison
    • Mixotrophs & Mixotrophy WG
    • N-Fixation WG
    • Ocean Carbonate System Intercomparison Forum
    • Ocean Carbon Uptake WG
    • Ocean Nucleic Acids ‘Omics
    • OOI BGC sensor working group
    • Phytoplankton Taxonomy WG
  • Science Support
    • Data management and archival
    • Early Career
    • Funding Sources
    • Jobs & Postdocs
    • Meeting List
    • OCB topical websites
      • Ocean Fertilization
      • Trace gases
      • US IIOE-2
    • Outreach & Education
    • Promoting your science
    • Student Opportunities
    • OCB Activity Proposal Solicitations
    • Travel Support
  • Publications
    • Ocean Carbon Exchange
    • Newsletter Archive
    • Science Planning and Policy
    • OCB Workshop Reports
  • OCB Science Highlights
  • News

Ocean Carbonate System Intercomparison Forum

Summary

Recent literature has highlighted several ongoing challenges regarding the consistency of seawater CO2 measurements with estimates from alternate input pairs. These gaps in our knowledge of the ocean carbonate system are probably related to carbonate constant uncertainties, frequently-unknown concentrations of organic bases in seawater, and unrecognized measurement uncertainties. CO2 measurement intercomparability is also challenged by the large and growing variety of instruments and approaches used for measurements and the lack of robust assessments or certified reference materials for some methods. While measurement strategies diversify and evolve, the need remains for consistent records of key measurements over time to assess marine CO2 cycling and its impacts: e.g. dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC) records for anthropogenic carbon storage and changes in the biological pump, partial pressure of CO2 (pCO2) records for air-sea CO2 flux estimates, pH records for ocean acidification (OA) monitoring, and seawater alkalinity (AT) records for assessing the impacts of OA on carbonate mineral cycling. It is therefore more critical than ever that scientists develop a strategy for identifying and addressing carbonate system intercomparability uncertainties, thus enabling existing and future data to be reconciled into internally-consistent data products with associated uncertainties. We therefore propose a forum between experts in carbonate system parameter measurements, data documentation, and interconversion to debate the nature of the problems, advocate for needed research to resolve these problems, and provide guidance for data product assembly and documentation.

View/download the proposal

Meetings Dates

June 22-23, 2019: First meeting (Woods Hole, MA)

June 29 2020: Second meeting (virtual)

OCSIF_photo_600

OCB workshop report: Ocean Carbonate System intercomparison Forum

The first of two OCB-funded meetings was held in Woods Hole, MA, June 22-23 by a team of researchers working on identifying the largest remaining challenges for internal consistency of the carbonate system in seawater. Discussion primarily focused on disagreements between measured and calculated seawater pH and on proposing efforts aimed at identifying the source of the disagreements. An inter-laboratory comparison experiment is being planned for the beginning of 2020 that will isolate aspects of seawater pH measurement practices, for example by providing a common purified dye for measurements by all groups and a reference material that is more strongly buffered and less strongly temperature sensitive than alternatives. Other major topics of debate included:

  • the need for standard distributable purified m-Cresol purple dye,
  • the feasibility of creating reference materials seawater pH,
  • the importance of routine measurement of non-certified reference materials for pH,
  • the inter-consistency of the other aspects of the carbonate system (beyond pH),
  • the need for additional independent discrete pCO2 measurements,
  • the need for a refinement to the boron-to-salinity ratio in seawater,
  • the need for a refinement to the carbonate system equilibrium coefficients,
  • best practices for inter-cruise comparisons during data product assembly in light of apparent inter-consistency challenges (i.e. recommendations for GLODAPv2),
  • many aspects of measurement practices that could be leading to observed or potential inter-consistency challenges (e.g. errors in the pressure dependence of carbonate constants)
  • and ways to make certified reference materials and purified (or well-characterized) dyes more broadly and inexpensively available.

The main conclusions of the OCSIF team should be made available following their 2nd meeting planned for summer of 2020.

Members

Brendan Carter
Brendan Carter
Marta Alvarez
Marta Alvarez
Leticia Barbero
Leticia Barbero
Robert Byrne
Robert Byrne
Wei-Jun Cai
Wei-Jun Cai
Melissa Chierici
Melissa Chierici
Andrew Dickson
Andrew Dickson
Regina Easley
Regina Easley
Andrea Fassbender
Andrea Fassbender
Akihiko Murata
Akihiko Murata
Yui Takeshita
Yui Takeshita
Nancy Williams
Nancy Williams
Ryan Woosley
Ryan Woosley

Brendan Carter (Lead) - NOAA Pacific Marine Environmental Laboratory

Marta Álvarez - Instituto Español de Oceanografia

Leticia Barbero - NOAA Atlantic Oceanographic and Meteorological Laboratory

Robert Byrne - University of South Florida

Wei-Jun Cai - University of Delaware

Melissa Chierici - Institute of Marine Research

Andrew Dickson - Scripps Institution of Oceanography

Regina Easley - National Institute of Standards and Technology

Andrea Fassbender - Monterey Bay Aquarium Research Institute

Akihiko Murata - Japan Agency for Marine-Earth Science and Technology

Yui Takeshita - Monterey Bay Aquarium Research Institute

Nancy Williams - NOAA Pacific Marine Environmental Laboratory

Ryan Woosley - Massachusetts Institute of Technology

 

Copyright © 2021 - OCB Project Office, Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution, 266 Woods Hole Rd, MS #25, Woods Hole, MA 02543 USA Phone: 508-289-2838  •  Fax: 508-457-2193  •  Email: ocb_news@us-ocb.org

link to nsflink to noaalink to WHOI

Funding for the Ocean Carbon & Biogeochemistry Project Office is provided by the National Science Foundation (NSF) and the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA). The OCB Project Office is housed at the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution.