Recent literature has highlighted several ongoing challenges regarding the consistency of seawater CO2 measurements with estimates from alternate input pairs. These gaps in our knowledge of the ocean carbonate system are probably related to carbonate constant uncertainties, frequently-unknown concentrations of organic bases in seawater, and unrecognized measurement uncertainties. CO2 measurement intercomparability is also challenged by the large and growing variety of instruments and approaches used for measurements and the lack of robust assessments or certified reference materials for some methods. While measurement strategies diversify and evolve, the need remains for consistent records of key measurements over time to assess marine CO2 cycling and its impacts: e.g. dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC) records for anthropogenic carbon storage and changes in the biological pump, partial pressure of CO2 (pCO2) records for air-sea CO2 flux estimates, pH records for ocean acidification (OA) monitoring, and seawater alkalinity (AT) records for assessing the impacts of OA on carbonate mineral cycling. It is therefore more critical than ever that scientists develop a strategy for identifying and addressing carbonate system intercomparability uncertainties, thus enabling existing and future data to be reconciled into internally-consistent data products with associated uncertainties. We therefore propose a forum between experts in carbonate system parameter measurements, data documentation, and interconversion to debate the nature of the problems, advocate for needed research to resolve these problems, and provide guidance for data product assembly and documentation.
View/download the proposal
- Álvarez, Marta, Noelia M. Fajar, Brendan R. Carter, Elisa F. Guallart, Fiz F. Pérez, Ryan J. Woosley, and Akihiko Murata. Global Ocean Spectrophotometric pH Assessment: Consistent Inconsistencies. Environmental Science & Technology. 2020. 54 (18), 10977-10988. DOI: 10.1021/acs.est.9b06932
- Fong, Michael B. , Andrew G. Dickson. Insights from GO-SHIP hydrography data into the thermodynamic consistency of CO2 system measurements in seawater. Marine Chemistry. 2019. Vol 211, 52-36. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marchem.2019.03.006.
- Li, Xinyu, Maribel I. García-Ibáñez, Brendan R. Carter, Baoshan Chen, Qian Li, Regina A. Easley, Wei-Jun Cai. Purified meta-Cresol Purple dye perturbation: How it influences spectrophotometric pH measurements. Marine Chemistry. 2020. Vol 225. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marchem.2020.103849.
- Olsen, Are, Nico Lange, Robert M. Key, Toste Tanhua, Henry C. Bittig, Alex Kozyr, Marta Álvarez, Kumiko Azetsu-Scott, Susan Becker, Peter J. Brown, Brendan R. Carter, Leticia Cotrim da Cunha, Richard A. Feely, Steven van Heuven, Mario Hoppema, Masao Ishii, Emil Jeansson, Sara Jutterström, Camilla S. Landa, Siv K. Lauvset, Patrick Michaelis, Akihiko Murata, Fiz F. Pérez, Benjamin Pfeil, Carsten Schirnick, Reiner Steinfeldt, Toru Suzuki, Bronte Tilbrook, Anton Velo, Rik Wanninkhof, and Ryan J. Woosley. An updated version of the global interior ocean biogeochemical data product, GLODAPv2.2020. Earth Syst. Sci. Data. 2020. 12, 3653–3678. https://doi.org/10.5194/essd-12-3653-2020
- Schockman, Katelyn M., Robert H. Byrne. Spectrophotometric determination of the bicarbonate dissociation constant in seawater. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta. 2021. Vol 300, 231-245. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gca.2021.02.008.
- Sharp, Jonathan D. , Robert H. Byrne. Interpreting measurements of total alkalinity in marine and estuarine waters in the presence of proton-binding organic matter. Deep Sea Research Part I: Oceanographic Research Papers. 2020. Vol 165, 103338. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.dsr.2020.103338.
- Takeshita, Yuichiro, Kenneth S. Johnson, Luke J. Coletti, Hans W. Jannasch, Peter M. Walz, Joseph K. Warren. Assessment of pH dependent errors in spectrophotometric pH measurements of seawater. Marine Chemistry. 2020. Vol 223, 103801. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marchem.2020.103801.
- Takeshita, Yuichiro, Joseph K. Warren, Xuewu Liu, Reggie S. Spaulding, Robert H. Byrne, Brendan R. Carter, Michael D. DeGrandpre, Akihiko Murata, Shu-ichi Watanabe. Consistency and stability of purified meta-cresol purple for spectrophotometric pH measurements in seawater. Marine Chemistry. 2021. Vol 236 , 104018. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marchem.2021.104018
- Woosley, Ryan J. . Evaluation of the temperature dependence of dissociation constants for the marine carbon system using pH and certified reference materials. Marine Chemistry. 2021, Vol 229 , 103914. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marchem.2020.103914
June 22-23, 2019: First meeting (Woods Hole, MA)
June 29, 2020: Second meeting (virtual)
August 11, 2021: Third meeting (virtual)
OCB workshop report: Ocean Carbonate System intercomparison Forum
The first of two OCB-funded meetings was held in Woods Hole, MA, June 22-23, 2019 by a team of researchers working on identifying the largest remaining challenges for internal consistency of the carbonate system in seawater. Discussion primarily focused on disagreements between measured and calculated seawater pH and on proposing efforts aimed at identifying the source of the disagreements. An inter-laboratory comparison experiment is being planned for the beginning of 2020 that will isolate aspects of seawater pH measurement practices, for example by providing a common purified dye for measurements by all groups and a reference material that is more strongly buffered and less strongly temperature sensitive than alternatives. Other major topics of debate included:
- the need for standard distributable purified m-Cresol purple dye,
- the feasibility of creating reference materials seawater pH,
- the importance of routine measurement of non-certified reference materials for pH,
- the inter-consistency of the other aspects of the carbonate system (beyond pH),
- the need for additional independent discrete pCO2 measurements,
- the need for a refinement to the boron-to-salinity ratio in seawater,
- the need for a refinement to the carbonate system equilibrium coefficients,
- best practices for inter-cruise comparisons during data product assembly in light of apparent inter-consistency challenges (i.e. recommendations for GLODAPv2),
- many aspects of measurement practices that could be leading to observed or potential inter-consistency challenges (e.g. errors in the pressure dependence of carbonate constants)
- and ways to make certified reference materials and purified (or well-characterized) dyes more broadly and inexpensively available.
Working Group Members
Brendan Carter (Lead) - NOAA Pacific Marine Environmental Laboratory
Marta Álvarez - Instituto Español de Oceanografia
Leticia Barbero - NOAA Atlantic Oceanographic and Meteorological Laboratory
Robert Byrne - University of South Florida
Wei-Jun Cai - University of Delaware
Melissa Chierici - Institute of Marine Research
Andrew Dickson - Scripps Institution of Oceanography
Regina Easley - National Institute of Standards and Technology
Andrea Fassbender - Monterey Bay Aquarium Research Institute
Akihiko Murata - Japan Agency for Marine-Earth Science and Technology
Yui Takeshita - Monterey Bay Aquarium Research Institute
Nancy Williams - NOAA Pacific Marine Environmental Laboratory
Ryan Woosley - Massachusetts Institute of Technology